A witness heard the 19 year old El Paso shooter respond to the question, “Why are you doing this?” with this chilling response, “I’m really angry.” He fits the profile of, the rage-induced young men we first encountered through Columbine and later Sandy Hook, Aurora, Charleston, Virginia Beach, the STEM school shooting in Colorado, Charlotte, the Poway synagogue shooting in California, the Louisiana shootings in two parishes, the Sebring shootings in Florida (those last six this year alone), the Mercy Hospital shooting, the Thousand Oaks shooting, the Tallahassee yoga studio shooting, the Jacksonville Landing shooting, the Art All Night shooting in New Jersey, the Santa Fe HS (Texas) shooting, the Nashville Waffle House shooting, the Marjory Stoneman Douglas HS shooting — and far too many more to mention, but all with one thing in common.
These killers all have a specific strain of anger — deep, repressed, biblically vengeful. — felt most commonly by young men, almost always white, who report feeling alienated, dispossessed, misunderstood, victimized and all too often rejected by women. The obvious questions are why has this happened and consequently what can we do about it?
In education, in popular culture, in the family and the workplace and society at large we need to examine the way we now raise and regard boys and young men. It’s a culture that defines boys’ natural rambunctiousness as ADHD and medicates it, that offers few truly positive role models — with TV, painting most men, both black and white, as bumbling and not-too-bright. In addition, many women believe that all men cheat on their wives because their fathers cheated and that men inherently lie and are not loyal.
Labeling and targeting
“toxic masculinity” as if masculinity were a force to be suppressed
rather than redefined as a positive aspect in our society further exacerbates
the issue. Many of our boys who are not
at the shooter level but are still confused about what it means to be a man in
the “Me Too” era are searching for a model of masculinity that is
non-patriarchal but still values masculine energy and allows boys to be ok
about being a man.